imranshaykh

Dear Zhang, the discussion here is about the Bahai Faith and not about Imam Ali. When we want to discuss about Ali, we will start a new thread.

Please feel free to criticize my site and help me to correct the errors. Though frankly, I don't think that the web site is full of grammatical errors that one will dismiss it. Your statement reeks of desperation to disparage the site, but that's ok. I have seen worse. Having said that, if you read the page on why this web site, it says that "it is for making Muslims and Bahais aware of lesser known facts about the Bahai Faith." At no place does it say that it is a lesson in English grammar!

I think you must be sleeping when you say that there is no proof or citation on the site. Please write to me at imranshaykh@gmail.com and send me which parts of the web site are without any citations. I will be either happy to correct them or take them off. This is my open challenge to you. Please let me know what is the quid pro quo from your side if the citations are established to be correct.

Zhang

Not true, it is very relevant. It is a very important factor in determining the background by which you make your claims. But, per your request, I will not bring this issue up again.

Entire articles are full of grammatical errors. It is not a disparaged attempt to discredit the site, such a practice is not scholarly and leads me to believe that you wrote such things down in an emotional rush, as opposed to a thought out, objective look at various points of the faith. Your article on Abdul Husain Aayati is one of many.

You quote many of the verses of the Aqdas in an attempt to show how "barbaric" the faith is. And yet, we are equally capable of quote mining in an effort to show evil. However we understand that there are reasons for these verses that not all men understand.

Surat An-Nisā' 4:89

I know of the many apologetic views of this, just as we have an equal number for our faith. The only difference is that we respect the Prophet Muhammad (S.A.W), just as we do all religions. When in context, we see a very different story painted, one that encourages Muslims to resist persecution but to be warned that ALLAH will judge them for their actions even in times of war.

We teach love and tolerance, your website attempts to create disunity among us. Words from the Prophet (S.A.W.)

Surat Al-Kāfirūn 109:1-6

Please echo His voice.

-张

InvestigateTruth

Well, I have read some parts of your site a few years back. Everything that I saw was only false and misleading info. I would not mind if you could really show some true info.
It takes too much time to reply to your too many false info you put there, but anyone who is a seeker of truth, can realize they are false info.
And the reason I said I have a feeling you get paid is that, you must have spent a lot of time on that, and every where else.
I have read the Baha'i Scriptures in original language, and they are perfect.

What you do is only fallacy!!!

tonyfish58

imranshaykh -

I like to make my own decisions re Faith but thanks for the advice and yes I will Turn towards the Prophet and His Word to make my choices.

This is what history has taught us. It is the learned of the age that are the first to reject the prophet. So it is on no surprise they have rejected Baha'u'llah

The Baha'i Faith is far from being shallow in thought and concepts. The words of Baha'u'llah are the highest form of wisdom that is available to mankind at this time and it is to them we must turn.

So we will have to agree that I will go my way and you will go your way. I wish you well in life & Faith.

Regards Tony

Napkin

Its just marketing. My bahai community = 70. most number of people at the feast = 10. most number of people at a fundraising where 400 were invited = under 20.

Napkin

Iphone is the best smart phone in the world.
Source: apple.com

lol

Napkin

A great idea that will never happen. The numbers from treasurer's office would contradict the numbers from bahai.com badly.

imranshaykh

Dear Investigate Truth, you keep on making this statement that everything on my site is false. I respect your opinion. Please let me know which references are false and I will take them off. I don't believe you have even heard of half of the books which I have quoted on the site.

In any case, there is an open challenge to all, that wrong references will be taken off if proved incorrect.

InvestigateTruth

Generally most of your arguments is fallacy.
Each one of the topics that you included in your site needs to be discussed in a separate thread.
You have the opportunity here, to make separate thread for each topic to discuss.
You put them on your site and claiming you would take them off if proved wrong. How could one prove them to you they are wrong, if we cannot discuss them openly?
giving your email, is not a proper way for an open discussion. How would anyone know, you simply do not ignore the comments, or the proofs?
To be honest with you, I personally even don't care about your site, or if you add or remove any information there. You take yourself too serious my friend.


Even your statement here is a fallacy.

What do you mean by 'open' challenge? Open challenge is only when, you have an open forum, and in each thread you discuss them openly. making a website and giving an email is not considered an open challenge.

You should only use the references in your site that are proved to be correct if you are of those who judge fairly. You are the one who needs to prove your sources are correct, and your interpretations are correct.

Anyhow, everyone is free to read Baha'i Scriptures and look at Baha'i View, as well as other sources including your site to decide for himself.

imranshaykh

This has been an open forum, right? I gave you the reference of Ishraqaat, page 293 wherein Bahaullah says that Prophet Mohammed is the last of the prophet and the messengers. Tell me that reference is incorrect. Also, you have no authority to interpret the words of Bahaullah. So please let me know what AB and SE said about the verse.

For Bahais, my site is a goldmine of information because the UHJ hides these books from the Bahais. Less than 200 years and the words of the Bab are lost? Why does the UHJ not publish the words of the Bab. I'll tell you why - because the words of the Bab contradict the Bahai Faith and are embarrassing for the Bahais. That's why. So if you want to know what is actually written in the Bahai Faith in its original languages, you should refer to my site.

Regards,

InvestigateTruth

If you had read, the Quran properly, as well as the writings of Baha'u'llah, you had your answers. That tells me you did not read, nor understood.

"The Prophetic Cycle hath, verily, ended. The Eternal Truth is now come" - Baha'u'llah

Lawh-i-Hasan-i-Sháhábadí


“Let him then who hopeth to attain the presence of his Lord work a righteous work.” Qur’án 18:111